With the sun shining and the heat rising, you’d think horror movies would be the last thing people would want to watch.
But horror is an evergreen genre, and Prime Video keeps adding new, scream-worthy films that demand your attention no matter the time of year.
Watch With Us has curated a list of the best horror movies to watch in May, with the 2025 hit Weapons at the top.
We also recommend streaming two older titles: 2001’s Jeepers Creepers, starring Justin Long, and 1983’s Psycho II, featuring Anthony Perkins reprising his iconic role as Norman Bates.
