If you’re itching for your next mystery or crime obsession, Amazon Prime Video has enough whodunnits to keep you guessing all year long.
Whether you prefer lighter crime-solving capers like Castle or the intensity of Broadchurch, there’s something on Prime that will satisfy every mystery fan.
For September 2025, the Watch With Us team has pulled together a list of our favorite crime and mystery shows on Prime Video — check out our faves, featuring actors like Nathan Fillion and Hugh Dancy, below!
Need more recommendations? Then check out the Best New Shows on Netflix, Max, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video and More, the Best Movies on Amazon Prime Video Right Now, the Best British Crime Shows on Right Now and the Must-Watch Reality Shows on Prime Video.
