Happy August, Watch With Us readers!
Every month, our favorite streaming services shuffle their content around, and Amazon Prime Video is no exception.
This month’s lineup adds the original Cape Fear, a psychological thriller from 1962. You may be familiar with the Martin Scorsese 1991 remake, but if you’re a fan of thrillers and suspense, this is a must-see.
This psychological cat-and-mouse game remains one of the most suspenseful films of its era. Let’s break down why you should stream the original Cape Fear this month.
Robert Mitchum Is Scary Without Saying Much
While later thrillers leaned on graphic violence, Cape Fear (1962) proves how much can be accomplished with suggestion and restraint. Robert Mitchum plays Max Cady with a calm, methodical presence — his quiet threats and unwavering stare are far more chilling than shouting or gore. Mitchum, known for his role in The Night of the Hunter, channels a similar kind of slow-burn menace here, giving Cady a sense of terrifying inevitability.
10 Greatest Thrillers of the 1990s, Ranked
His performance is iconic — a master class in how to be truly frightening without ever raising your voice. While Robert De Niro‘s portrayal of the role in 1991 was perhaps more complex, Mitchum lays the groundwork here that would go on to influence the genre for decades to come.
Gregory Peck Plays an Everyman Hero With Depth
Gregory Peck stars as Sam Bowden, a mild-mannered Southern lawyer whose family becomes the target of Cady’s revenge after Sam testifies against him in court. The film smartly raises moral questions about justice, obligation and guilt. The character starts out similar to Atticus Finch, who Peck famously portrayed in To Kill a Mockingbird later that same year, but he is pushed to the edge of his own morality by the constant threat of Cady.
Sam is a man trying to uphold the law in a situation where the law doesn’t seem to be working. It’s a compelling portrait of a man caught between morality and survival, and a surprisingly complex critique of the justice system.
One of Netflix’s Most-Watched Movies Right Now Is This Underrated 1995 Thriller
The Suspense Is Hitchcock-Level Brilliant
Though not directed by Alfred Hitchcock, Cape Fear has all the trademarks of a Hitchcock thriller: a sense of claustrophobia, dramatic lighting, a haunting musical score and extended sequences of unbearable suspense. It functions as evidence of Hitchcock’s influence on filmmaking and the evolution of the thriller genre. Director J. Lee Thompson uses silence and shadows to keep viewers constantly on edge, and the score by Bernard Herrmann (a frequent Hitchcock collaborator) is unforgettable.
16 Must-Watch Thrillers on HBO Max Right Now (August 2025)
The 1962 version of Cape Fear feels like it could easily sit on a shelf next to Psycho or Rear Window. It’s classic suspense done right, and the movie’s influence is keenly felt in future psychological thrillers — not just the Scorsese remake, but in movies as diverse as Se7en and even The Dark Knight.
Watch Cape Fear on Amazon Prime Video.
