The Valley’s reunion show isn’t complete without some shocking unseen footage.
In Us Weekly’s exclusive sneak peek of the Tuesday, August 5, episode of the three-part reunion show, Jesse Lally and Michelle Saniei are put in the hot seat when their divorce is discussed amongst the group.
“Do you think that you emotionally cheated on Jesse a little bit?” Jasmine Goode asks during part two of the reunion special. “That’s what it sounds like to me.”
While Michelle continues to deny she was unfaithful during her marriage, Jesse, 43, isn’t convinced. He claims Michelle’s very own boyfriend, Aaron Nosler, said things that prove otherwise.
‘The Valley’ Stars Jesse Lally and Michelle Lally’s Relationship Timeline
“That is so false because he admitted to me in Hawaii that you guys used to meet up at the park while [our daughter] Isabella ran around and he used to ask you for advice on his girls he was dating,” Jesse explains at the reunion. “His words: You asked him for advice on our marriage and our separation.”
In a surprise twist, Bravo begins to play unseen footage from the cast trip to Hawaii.
In the clip, Aaron, 38, has a one-on-one chat with Jesse and tries to set the record straight on what his private conversations with Michelle, 36, were about.
“I would tell her about all these girls I was dating and I’d get her opinion on them,” he shared. “The only time she brought you guys up was when she was about to file for separation from you.”
From Jesse’s point of view, that’s more than enough proof to prove his estranged wife’s relationship with Aaron was inappropriate.
“Come on!” he says in the clip. “A married woman with a child asking a single guy for advice about her husband? That’s wildly inappropriate.”
Michelle adds, “Wildly inappropriate? You told our client that you wanted to eat her out.”
Before The Valley premiered in March 2024, Us exclusively confirmed that Jesse and Michelle had split after six years of marriage. Since then, cameras have rolled as the pair tried to coparent and move on with their lives.
Celebrity Splits of 2025: Stars Who Have Called It Quits This Year
On July 24, Us broke the news that Aaron and Michelle had broken up after one year of dating.
At the time, a source said Michelle is “focusing on her daughter, work and taking care of herself as she navigates this new chapter in her life.”
The Valley airs on Bravo Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET. Stream old episodes anytime on Peacock.
