Farmer Wants a Wife sparked several romantic connections — but which couples are still dating and who has broken up?
Based on a British series of the same name, Farmer Wants a Wife premiered on The CW in 2008. It didn’t return for another season until Fox announced a reboot in 2023, with Allen Foster, Ryan Black, Hunter Grayson and Landon Heaton becoming the newest group of eligible single farmers.
Season 2 aired in 2024 with Brandon Rogers, Mitchell Kolinsky, Nathan Smothers and Ty Ferrell looking for love, while season 3 introduced Us to John Sansone, Jay Woods, Matt Warren and Colton Hendricks as they searched for The One.
Jennifer Nettles hosted the first two seasons in America before Kimberly Williams-Paisley was brought in for season 3. While most couples broke up in the months after filming the show, some lasted longer.
Failed Reality TV Romances Over the Years
Scroll down to find out whether your favorite Farmer Wants a Wife couple is still together:
Allen Foster and Khelsi Stone
Days after the season 1 finale aired in 2023, Allen Foster confirmed his split from Khelsi Stone, writing via Instagram, “What an incredible journey and opportunity this has been! I came into this with an open mind and open heart!”
He continued: “Farmer Wants a Wife didn’t end how I’d [hoped] as far as a relationship, however, I have gained friendships and had opportunities that will last a lifetime!”
Hunter Grayson and Meghan Baker
Hunter Grayson and Meghan Baker ended the first season together but have since called it quits.
“I’ve never in my life had to make a break up post before so bear with me,” she wrote via Facebook in 2024. “Break ups are hard enough without having to post about them but I guess this is what I get for signing up for this wild adventure. God only knows who he has in store for my life. I know that He put me on #farmerwantsawife for a reason. Thank you all for following along on ‘our’ journey. Please remember we are both human and sometimes things just don’t work out, but we wish each other the best!”
Landon Heaton and Ashley Larea
Ashley Larea broke her silence about her split from Landon Heaton right after their finale aired in 2023.
“After the show stopped filming, the pressure of things beyond my control took a toll and ultimately we decided to go our separate ways,” she wrote via Instagram while Heaton cited “unforeseen circumstances” as the reason for their split, adding, “I know what I was looking for going into this, but wasn’t sure what I’d find.”
He continued, “What I found was an amazing raw connection with a fantastic person. Following the final days of filming, due to unforeseen circumstances, I needed to be home with my family, and then life got busy. Ashley and I made the decision to go our separate way in January 2023, in an effort to adjust back to ‘normal life.’”
Ryan Black and Haley Ramirez
Ryan Black and Haley Ramirez parted ways during the season 1 finale, which aired in 2023.
Brandon Rogers and Grace Girard
During the season 2 reunion in 2024, Brandon Rogers and Grace Girard revealed they were no longer together.
Mitchell Kolinsky and Sydney Errera
The pair were one of the few lasting connections on the show during season 2, but their happy ending didn’t last forever. In October 2025, Mitchell Kolinsky raised eyebrows when eagle-eyed fans noticed he no longer followed Sydney Errera on social media. Errera confirmed in February 2026 that she and Kolinsky had split “over two months ago” after being together for two years.
“I can confidently say that Mitchell and I gave our relationship 110 percent, more than I’ve ever given anything in my life,” Errera shared via TikTok. “I just recently moved back to Nashville because I really like it here and I want to give it another shot. Mitchell and I are on good terms, we’re friendly, and there’s no bad blood between us. I obviously still have love for him, he still has love for me, and hopefully we can just move forward nicely.”
Nathan Smothers and Taylor BeDell
Nathan Smothers and Taylor BeDell remained together almost a year after the season 2 reunion aired in 2024. Their romance has since fizzled out according to their social media.
Colton Hendricks and Zoë Green
Zoë Green and Colton Hendricks’ split was confirmed in the days after the season 3 finale aired on Fox in 2025.
Jay Woods and Grace Clark
Jay Woods cited a lack of chemistry for his and Grace Clark’s offscreen split after filming season 3.
John Sansone and Claire Dirette
John Sansone and Claire Dirette confirmed their split in August 2025 after they found love on the show.
“This was a mutual decision based on private challenges, and had nothing to do with any reposts. While I’ll always appreciate and respect the time we shared together, I feel it’s best to move forward separately,” he wrote via Instagram. “While our relationship was public, I wish for this chapter to remain as private as possible. Thank you for your kindness and support.”
Dirette reshared Sansone’s announcement via her Instagram Story and wrote, “I ain’t reading all that but ditto.”
Matt Warren and Chelsi Davis
Season 3 stars Matt Warren and Chelsi Davis were still together up until summer 2025 but are no longer a couple.
