Lisa Rinna’s daughters, Delilah Belle and Amelia Gray, have several famous men in their dating histories, but according to their mom, they could have had two more: Leonardo DiCaprio and Tobey Maguire.
Rinna, 62, spilled the tea during her appearance on the Wednesday, February 25, episode of Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen, where she played a game called “Trait-ing, Truth and Falsehoods.” The concept involved host Andy Cohen reading both truths and lies about Rinna, and he and the other guests had to determine which were true and which were false.
Most of the statements were true, but one particularly juicy one was false: Rinna’s friend did not bring DiCaprio, 51, and Maguire, 50, as guests to her 50th birthday party.
“I feel like that’s true, she’s so Hollywood,” said Cohen, 57, before Rinna confirmed that it didn’t happen.
Lisa Rinna Recalls ‘Uncomfortable’ Rift Between Daughters Amelia and Delilah
“False, but I love that you thought it was true,” she quipped.
Cohen then followed up by asking whether DiCaprio — famous for dating models who are much younger than he is — had ever “hit up” Delilah, 27, or Amelia, 24, whom she shares with husband Harry Hamlin.
“Yes,” Rinna replied. “Didn’t happen. But yes.”
Cohen then quipped, “I mean, isn’t it a rite of passage?”
Rinna then claimed that DiCaprio wasn’t the only A-lister to “hit up” her daughters, adding, “And so did Tobey Maguire. But a lot of ’em have hit the girls [up], as you know.”
The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum didn’t offer any further details or reveal when the alleged contact happened. She also claimed that Cohen knew about a different older man who shot his shot with her daughters (but she didn’t identify him).
Lisa Rinna and Harry Hamlin Recall Amelia’s Nightmare 13th B-Day in Paris
DiCaprio, who is currently dating Vittoria Ceretti, has long been known for his relationships with younger models. Ceretti, 27, is 24 years his junior and has been dating the Oscar winner since 2023. The One Battle After Another actor has previously been linked to Gisele Bündchen, Camila Morrone, Blake Lively, Bar Refaeli and Gigi Hadid.
Maguire, for his part, shares two kids with ex-wife Jennifer Meyer, whom he wed in 2007. Since their 2016 separation, he has been linked to Tatiana Dieteman and Lily Chee, both of whom are significantly younger than he is.
“They aren’t seriously dating but have been hanging out,” an insider told Us Weekly of Maguire and Chee in July 2024.
More recently, Maguire sparked dating rumors with 20-year-old model and influencer Mishka Silva after they were spotted sitting together at the Super Bowl earlier this month.
Lily Collins, Charlie McDowell and More Celebrity Kids Who Have Dated
Rinna’s daughter Amelia, meanwhile, famously dated Scott Disick, who is 18 years her senior, from 2020 to 2021. At the time, Rinna wasn’t overly supportive of the relationship.
“Very similar to what you thought when you met him, he’s more handsome in person,” she told Cohen in May 2021. “We had a very nice time. He met Harry. … It is what it is, guys. It is what it is.”
After their split, Rinna commented on a post from Instagram fan account Queens of Bravo, which shared a screenshot of the breakup story in September 2021. In response, Rinna simply added a smiley face emoji.
