Paul W. Downs and Megan Stalter channeled their favorite couple at the 2026 Critics Choice Awards.
Downs, 43, and Stalter, 35, looked just like Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner at the awards show, which took place at the Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, California, on Sunday, January 4. For the red carpet event, they wore replicas of the bright orange Chrome Hearts outfits that Chalamet, 30, and Jenner, 28, wore at the Los Angeles premiere of Marty Supreme in December 2025.
Downs rocked an orange dress shirt lined with silver buttons and a leather blazer. He completed his outfit with a black Chrome Hearts ping-pong paddle, which he slung over his shoulder, and orange boots.
Stalter wore nearly the same dress as Jenner, featuring a bra top with cutouts over her side and a knee-high slit. Just like the reality star, she accessorized with a large silver cross necklace and delicate bracelet. When Jenner wore the look, her dress was finished with a bodycon skirt.
Critics Choice Awards 2026 Red Carpet: All the Best Looks
Downs was nominated for Best Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series for his turn as Jimmy LuSaque Jr. in Hacks, but the award went to Ike Barinholtz for his role in The Studio. Hacks was also nominated for Best Comedy Series, which The Studio won. Downs’ costar Jean Smart took home the award for Best Actress in a Comedy Series, while Hannah Einbinder was up for Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series. (Janelle James won the latter award for her role in Abbott Elementary.)
Neither Chalamet nor Jenner walked the red carpet at the Critics Choice Awards, but they were photographed together inside the venue.
Jenner sparkled in a crystal-embellished dress equipped with a low-cut neckline that exposed lace details of her bra. She teamed the design with diamond stud earrings, long lashes, blushed cheeks and pink lips. Her hair was parted slightly to the side and styled in big, bouncy curls.
Chalamet wrapped his arm around his girlfriend while wearing a striped blazer, a white dress shirt and a colorful tie. (Chalamet is nominated for Best Actor for his role as Marty in Marty Supreme.)
Chalamet and Jenner started dating in 2023. Jenner has supported him at several awards shows through the years, including the 2024 and 2025 Golden Globes. She also attended the 2025 Oscars alongside Chalamet.
The couple made their red carpet debut at the David di Donatello Awards in Rome, Italy, in May 2025.
For the event, Jenner stunned in a sexy black Schiaparelli dress featuring delicate embroidery, a plunging scoop neckline, a fitted bodice and a delicate train. The design was finished with an open back.
Timothee Chalamet and Kylie Jenner Steal the Show at Critics Choice Awards
Jenner let the dress speak for itself, opting for simple jewelry, including gold dangling earrings. She styled the look with a black clutch adorned with gold details.
The Kylie Cosmetics founder wore her brunette hair in a slicked-back updo, which she complemented with soft glam, including mascara, lined lips, rosy cheeks and a touch of bronze eyeshadow.
Chalamet, for his part, looked sharp in a black double-breasted blazer, which he wore with a white floral pin, a dark dress shirt and straight pants.
