Netflix already has so many shows in its library that it might feel overwhelming when they add even more every month.
Between a wealth of Netflix originals in addition to countless series from other networks, it might seem like an impossible task choosing what to stream next.
To help you out, the Watch With Us team picked three series that are new to Netflix and ranked them according to their IMDb scores.
These diverse picks include a sci-fi thriller about clones, a musical drama about country musicians, and an original documentary series about romance scam victims.
3 New on Netflix Shows With at Least 90 Percent on Rotten Tomatoes (September 2025)
3. ‘Love Con Revenge’ (2025-present)
With the help of the “Tinder Swindler” victim Cecilie Fjellhøy alongside private investigator Brianne Joseph, this documentary series follows the two women as they help victims of romance scams similar to the one of the center of one of Netflix’s most popular true crime documentaries ever. Fjellhøy has gone from victim to defender, using her experience with the notorious scammers to avenge other casualties of similar frauds.
The series sees Fjellhøy and Joseph tackle multiple scam victims who have reached out to Fjellhøy for assistance. They, too, have been defrauded by seemingly loving partners who only reveal themselves to be seeking resources — once they drain their victim, they disappear. It’s a fascinating follow-up to 2022’s The Tinder Swindler and an infuriating portrait of romantic exploitation.
Love Con Revenge is streaming on Netflix.
2. ‘Nashville’ (2012-2018)
While it received positive reviews, Nashville had a rocky time when it first aired. It was cancelled by its original broadcaster, ABC, after four seasons, and then was resurrected by CMT and ran for an additional two, after which it concluded. The series starred Connie Britton and Hayden Panettiere as dueling country singers — the old guard versus the rising star, including an eclectic cast of characters in this fictional country music scene.
Rayna James (Britton) has always been the queen of country, but as times change, she has struggled to keep her act relevant. Things become more difficult for James with the rising star of Juliette Barnes (Panettiere), a sexy singer with a troubled past who is determined to steal James’ crown.
Nashville is streaming on Netflix.
1. ‘Orphan Black’ (2013-2017)
This Canadian sci-fi series ran for four seasons and was nominated for a slew of awards during its run, including a Primetime Emmy and Golden Globe win for lead actress Tatiana Maslany. Maslany stars as Sarah Manning, an English con artist and single mother residing in Toronto, whose life changes forever when she discovers that she is one of several clones.
28 Must-Watch Shows on Netflix Right Now (September 2025): ‘S.W.A.T.’ and More
When Sarah witnesses the suicide of a woman named Beth, who happens to look just like Sarah, she attempts to steal Beth’s identity to start a new life for her and her daughter. But taking on Beth’s life as a police officer proves more deadly than planned, and Sarah eventually learns that not only was Beth her clone, there are many clones of Sarah out there — and someone wants them all dead. The series follows Sarah and her clones in their struggle to evade capture from their creators and a fanatical religious movement.
Orphan Black is streaming on Netflix.
