Brooks Nader is maintaining an air of mystery around her dating life.
The Sports Illustrated swimsuit model, 28, was quizzed about recent speculation linking her to not one, but two tennis pros — Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner — during an appearance on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen on Wednesday, September 17.
A curious audience member asked Nader, “During the 2025 US open, did Carlos and Jannik know about each other?”
The Love Thy Nader star coyly responded, “I would just say, a lady never kisses and tells — especially twice, that’s just not nice!”
Brooks Nader Is Open to Dating Women After Gleb Savchenko Breakup
Nader’s sister Grace Ann chimed in from the studio audience, “Especially not to her other boyfriend.”
Host Andy Cohen then asked Nader if there was any truth to the rumors that she dated Spanish star Alcaraz, 22, and Italy’s Sinner, 24.
“Dating is such a loose term these days,” Nader responded.
“It’s just… I don’t know. By the way, my only thing is: guys do it all the time, so why can’t I do it?” she added, prompting a standing ovation from Cohen and fellow guest Mark Ronson, as well as cheers from the audience.
The Hottest Celeb Bikini Moments of 2025: Nina Dobrev, Kenzie Ziegler, More
Grace Ann recently told E! News that her sister was indeed dating US Open champion Alcaraz.
“The rumors are true,” Grace Ann, 25, said in a September 10 interview. “Dating is such a loose term, but I do know he’s the man of the hour.”
Grace Ann said she was “dying” to meet Alcaraz, adding: “[He’s] such a cutie.”
Nader has been linked to both Alcaraz and Sinner in recent weeks after she was seen at the US Open in New York City last month.
“Is this, like, an interrogation? I’m so scared right now,” Nader responded on the September 2 episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live when asked about her attendance at the US Open. “Well, ask Stephen [Colbert] what match we were at. I don’t think [Jannik] was playing in that one.”
Brooks Nader’s Most Relatable Moments: Normalizing Period Stains and More
Nader was spotted alongside The Late Show host Colbert and his wife, Evie, during Alcaraz’s August 31 match against French tennis pro Arthur Rinderknech.
For his part, Sinner has been linked to Danish model Laila Hasanovic after eagle-eyed viewers spotted a photo of her as his phone lock screen during the US Open.
Nader last dated Dancing With the Stars pro Gleb Savchenko, but the pair called it quits after nearly a year in April.
“[I’m] loving it,” Nader said of being single in an exclusive Us Weekly cover interview in August. “I’ve never gotten to do this my whole life, so I love it.”
