Amazon Prime Video isn’t the first streamer people think of when it comes to reality TV — but perhaps it should be.
Between the return of Judy Sheindlin and reality mainstays like Pawn Stars, the platform has plenty of star power — not to mention the shows featuring icons like Tim Gunn or Stacy London.
Whether you like your unscripted content catty or heartfelt, aspirational or funny, Prime has a show for you. Watch With Us recommends these series for your next reality TV binge.
‘Pawn Stars’ (2009-Present)
The Harrison family — Rick, Corey and Austin “Chumlee” — have been running the World Famous Gold & Silver Pawn Shop in Las Vegas for decades, so it’s safe to say they know their stuff. In Pawn Stars, they appraise interesting, rare and unique historical artifacts brought in by their customers, negotiating sales with their trademark humor and intelligence. The show offers viewers an opportunity to learn about history, business strategy and the unpredictable nature of the pawnbroker world.
5 Best Prime Video Shows of 2025 So Far, Ranked
Rick is known for his canny negotiation skills, Corey balances tradition with a fresh perspective, and Chumlee has a comedic charm that makes Pawn Stars an entertaining comfort show. The series also follows the interpersonal conflicts among the cast, mixing a pinch of drama in with the business.
‘Judy Justice’ (2021-Present)
Judy Sheindlin (aka Judge Judy) returns to family court — and our screens — with Judy Justice, a successor to her daytime series. Despite the higher production values, new set and fresh look, fans should have no fear — this is the same sharp, candid and honest judge you’ve known and loved for so many years. Plus, it’s now a family business — Judy’s granddaughter, Sarah Rose, joins as her grandma’s law clerk. The cases are more complex and the episodes are longer, but you’ll still recognize Judy’s signature style as she tackles these real-world conflicts.
14 Must-See Comedy Shows to Stream Right Now (May 2025)
Reality TV fans will find Judy Justice enjoyable due to its blend of drama, humor, and insightful commentary provided by the ever-charismatic star.
‘Second Chance Dresses’ (2018)
If you love Say Yes to the Dress but can’t help feeling sad about all those beautiful gowns yellowing in the back of a closet after that one special day, Second Chance Dresses is the show for you. In this sadly short-lived British reality series, host and Love Island alum Olivia Bowen (née Buckland) picks out secondhand wedding dresses for hopeful brides-to-be.
What’s really charming is that the shoppers get to interact with the brides who are selling their gowns, allowing them to bond and share their love stories. It’s a surprisingly emotional experience, and we love the way it turns vintage shopping into entertainment.
‘Born This Way’ (2015-2019)
This touching reality series follows a group of adults with Down syndrome as they work hard to achieve their dreams and overcome obstacles. They have their share of drama and setbacks, especially when it comes to dating, but these young adults are incredibly inspiring in the way they face their fears while seeking independence.
9 Must-Watch Reality Shows on Netflix Right Now (June 2025)
It’s an honest look at the lives of people with a disability — the challenges and the unexpected joys. Expect to shed a tear or two as Rachel Osterbach, Sean McElwee, John Tucker, Steven Clark, Cristina Sanz, Megan Bomgaars and Elena Ashmore reach life milestones and form a community in their quest for independence.
‘Wear Whatever the F You Want’ (2025-Present)
Clinton Kelly and Stacy London were known for their brutal honesty in What Not to Wear, a popular reality show where they gave makeovers to people whose friends and family nominated them because of their perceived “bad” style. In Wear Whatever the F You Want, the fashion gurus take a very different approach. Briefed in advance on their subjects’ dream aesthetic, they help them create a new wardrobe that helps their outside appearance reflect how they see themselves.
Wear Whatever is a warmer, fuzzier program, but it still showcases Kelly and London’s style and talent. It’s a positive spin on the makeover show, one that seeks to make the participant more themselves, rather than transforming them into someone else.
‘Tiny House Hunting’ (2014-2017)
Thinking of downsizing? In Tiny House Hunters, real estate pros take prospective home buyers to view the best in tiny houses. From portable micro-homes to woodsy mini-cabins, this show gives you an inside look at the creative ways the tiny house movement maximizes space while minimizing square footage.
It’s House Hunters with a miniaturized twist, and you’ll be surprised how quickly you get invested in the hopeful homeowners’ dreams, “small” as they may be.
‘Dance Life’ (2024-Present)
Brent Street Academy is Australia’s best dance academy, but even if you graduate from there, you’re not guaranteed a job as a dancer. In Dance Life, watch 90 high school seniors work relentlessly to achieve their dreams. The talent and dedication on display will amaze you, but so will the brutal nature of the dance world.
Competition is fierce in this series, which follows a year in the life of these incredible students. Dance Life is the perfect show for viewers who want to go behind the scenes of the performing arts world.
5 Great Fashion Movies to Watch for the 2025 Met Gala
‘Making the Cut’ (2020-2022)
Iconic fashion figures Heidi Klum and Tim Gunn, hosts of Project Runway, reunite for another fashion competition show, Making the Cut. In this series, Gunn and Klum don’t just test competitors on their design skills, but on their business abilities as well. Designers need to prove they have what it takes to run a global fashion brand.
The show culminates with the winner receiving $1 million to invest in their brand, along with the opportunity to sell their final collection on Amazon, providing both a financial and commercial launching pad. Competitors produce big-budget runway shows and travel to fashion capitals like Paris and Tokyo to complete their challenges. Fans love Making the Cut for its glamorous settings, high-stakes competition, and the familiar dynamic between Klum and Gunn.
‘Dog Whisperer with Cesar Millan’ (2004-2016)
We all love our furry friends, but sometimes their neuroses can make them downright annoying—or even dangerous. When this happens, it’s best to call in an expert like Cesar Millan, a professional dog trainer known for his unique ability to rehabilitate unruly and aggressive dogs. Dog Whisperer with Cesar Millan involves Millan traveling to various locations to help dog owners address behavioral issues with their pets.
Each episode typically features multiple cases, ranging from minor disobedience to severe aggression, highlighting Millan’s expertise in understanding and communicating with dogs through what he describes as a ‘calm-assertive’ approach. It’s a must-watch for dog owners seeking solutions or those who simply enjoy a fascinating view inside the animal mind.
‘Portrait Artist of the Year’ (2013-2020)
As anyone who’s ever taken a middle school art class can tell you, painting accurate portraits of people is really hard! This British series takes the best painters from around the U.K. and challenges them to not just paint accurate portraits, but to elevate them to creative heights. Each season, the talented painters are challenged to create likenesses of celebrity “sitters” like Sophie Turner, Sir Ian McKellen, Hannah Waddingham and many more.
11 Must-Watch Reality Shows on Peacock Right Now (August 2025)
Portrait Artist of the Year blends high-stakes competition and artistic exploration. The series appeals to audiences with its behind-the-scenes peek into the creative process and the personal stories of the artists, which add depth to the competition. It’s a beautiful examination of painting as a storytelling medium that fosters an appreciation for the arts.
