Jesse Lally claims to have evidence that may prove estranged wife Michelle Saniei wasn’t faithful during their marriage.
In Us Weekly’s exclusive sneak peek of the Tuesday, April 29, episode of The Valley, Jesse, 43, sits down with Kristen Doute and Luke Broderick to share his theory.
“I don’t actually know what’s going on with Michelle,” Jesse shares in the preview. “She’s most likely with her boyfriend [Aaron Nosler] for the last two years.”
The only problem with that is Jesse and Michelle, 36, haven’t been separated for two years.
The Valley’s Michelle Is Dating Someone After Split, Slams Cheating Rumors
“Nothing about Michelle and Aaron adds up,” Jesse adds in a confessional. “I think there was a situation that happened with the two of them while I was married.”
While chatting with Kristen, 42, and Luke, 34, Jesse points out the times his estranged wife started going on morning hikes near Runyon Canyon without wearing her wedding ring.
Another red flag to Jesse was Michelle always raving about Kilo honey, which is Aaron’s company.
When Jesse went looking for the beloved honey at a Whole Foods grocery store, he couldn’t find it. He claimed Michelle said she gets it at a place near Runyon, which is where Aaron lives.
“Michelle and I had a conversation before the summer where she admitted to cheating on me, and I’m 90 percent sure that this person was Aaron,” Jesse adds in a confessional. “If it wasn’t, she cheated on me twice.”
While Kristen has been outspoken about her belief that Michelle had a boyfriend during a part of her marriage to Jesse, she’s not sure Aaron is the right guy.
“Just to be clear, the guy I was talking about Michelle seeing last summer,” she said in a confessional, “that is not Aaron.”
Michelle has strongly denied any claims that she was unfaithful during her marriage to Jesse.
‘The Valley’ Stars Jesse Lally and Michelle Lally’s Relationship Timeline
Before The Valley kicked off season 1 in March 2024, Us Weekly exclusively confirmed that Michelle and Jesse had separated after nearly six years of marriage. Since then, cameras have been able to capture the couple struggling to get along as they coparent their 4-year-old daughter, Isabella.
“She swears up and down that Aaron has said that he would never date a married woman or never date a woman with a kid,” Jesse recalls. “There’s just too many things like his honey company that has been in my cabinet for two years.”
The Valley airs on Bravo Tuesdays at 9 p.m. ET. Catch up on old episodes anytime on Peacock.
