Lindsay Hubbard was on edge during the latest episode of Summer House after learning her ex-fiancé Carl Radke might’ve been messaging another woman when they were still together.
During the Wednesday, April 2, episode of the Bravo series, Carl’s summer flame, Lil, broke down when she first met him and the story raised eyebrows for both Lindsay, 38, and her bestie Gabby Prescod.
“He met, like, my whole family because my dad always goes to NYCFC games. Then they became buddies,” Lil revealed during Carl’s Soft Bar friends and family event, which was filmed in summer 2024. “And then I slid into his DMs.”
Gabby, 34, quickly questioned the timing, asking, “That was last summer right?” Lil looked like a deer in the headlights while mulling over the question.
Imrul Hassan chimed in to ask, “The NYCFC games?” to which Lil said, “Oh, yes, yes, yes.” Imurl then clarified, “So he’s kinda known you for a year at least,” which Lil said was correct.
“Last summer? When Lindsay and Carl were still very much engaged, he met your parents and then you slid into his DMs? That’s suspicious,” Gabby told the cameras after her awkward interaction.
‘Summer House’ Recap: Lindsay Hubbard Calls Carl Radke a ‘F–king Terrorist’
Earlier this season, Carl, 40, invited Lil to the group’s pirate party in the Hamptons. At the time, it seemed like he and Lil had recently connected, but according to her story on Wednesday’s episode they at least knew of each other when Carl was still engaged to Lindsay.
When Gabby debriefed Lindsay about the garden party for Carl’s future Soft Bar launch, Lindsay started to put together the pieces herself.
“There was one morning the last week of us being together. After the soccer game and before we broke up,” Lindsay recalled, referring to August 2023 events. “I went into his room, gave him a hug and on his phone, he had a DM open where somebody was sending their phone number. He swiped out of the DM immediately. … Now it’s all making sense to me.”
Lindsay Hubbard Says She Knew ‘Something’s Up’ Before Carl Radke Split
Lindsay pointed out that since Carl called off their engagement in August 2023, he’s been “going around Gabby being like, ‘Ah, I’m such a victim. I haven’t moved on. I haven’t moved on since Lindsay.’”
While Lindsay moved on with boyfriend Turner Kufe, with whom she welcomed daughter Gemma in December 2024, she was miffed that Carl seemingly lied about his romantic life.
“Meanwhile, bitch, you’ve been talking to a girl since before you broke up with me. So, you are once again gaslighting everyone, manipulating everyone,” Lindsay alleged. “You’re a f***ing fraud, you’re a phony, you’re a liar and now I’m adding cheater to your f***ing resume.”
Lindsay claimed that when Carl told the cameras last season that he didn’t expect to break up with her when he sat her down in their apartment he must have been lying. “You knew [your plan]! You were already talking to someone and her parents,” she quipped.
Elsewhere in the episode, Lindsay told Paige DeSorbo and Lexi Wood about Carl and Lil’s DMs, claiming they connected in August 2023.
‘Summer House’ Finale Shows Carl and Lindsay Split: How It Went Down
“He went to that soccer game. They start DMing each other before he ever broke up with me,” Lindsay revealed, noting, “But I’m the villain. You are lying to everyone around you that you’re such a victim.”
When asked whether she was going to speak with Carl about Lil’s remarks, Lindsay said, “F*** yeah, I’m going to confront him about it. I’ve got nothing to lose. … He’s a monster.”
Lindsay teased she would address the issue with Carl at a later date, which Bravo teased would be during next week’s Summer House episode.
Summer House airs on Bravo Wednesdays at 9 p.m. ET.
