The number of second homes being put up for sale in one part of Wales has increased by more than 250% – as homeowners and businesses criticise the Welsh government’s council tax premium.
Many councils in Wales now charge an inflated tax rate for second homes, up to 300%, with the aim of freeing up rarely used housing stock for locals and generating income.
In Pembrokeshire, the council tax premium increased to 200% in April, trebling the cost for homeowners and leading to many selling up.
Figures show that this July 135 second homes were listed for sale in the county, a rise of 255% compared to the 38 on the market at the same time last year.
Despite the influx of listings, actual sales are at a record low.
Estate agent Hamptons says second home sales accounted for just 4.5% of sales in Pembrokeshire in the first six months of 2024 – compared to 21% a decade ago.
Local agents say the properties coming onto the market are too expensive for first-time buyers – and that many homes are being listed in a loophole to avoid the increased tax.
Labour urged to honour promise to ban ‘no fault’ evictions as landmark bill returns to Commons
End Right to Buy to help save councils from £2.2bn black hole, government urged
Construction industry ‘roaring ahead’ after rebound in house building
Rhys Jordan, from Nested Estate Agent Pembrokeshire, told Sky News the new policy wasn’t working.
“Quite frankly, here in Pembrokeshire, wages are low. Anything in reach for first-time buyers needs to be below £250,000,” he said.
“All they’ve done is create a glut of unsuitable properties for long-term use on to the market,” he added.
Second homes for sale are exempt from council tax for up to one year and he said properties are “definitely” being listed to avoid the new council tax premium.
“There’s no denying that many properties are priced not to sell purely to sit on the market to avoid paying council tax,” he continued.
There are also concerns that falling numbers of second homeowners will hit the local economy.
Matthew Ronowitz runs three restaurants in Tenby, employing 75 people.
He told Sky News: “I think the influx of second homeowners has helped us get more of a 12-month year for business trade, which from my point of view is a positive thing.
“It does kind of worry me that if these second homeowners feel like they’re being pushed out by the local authority with the way that they’ve structured things.
“It could impact the business and for the jobs we are able to provide for local people.”
Read more from Sky News:
Strictly returns despite controversy
PM faces investigation over wife’s ‘free clothes’
Prince Harry turns 40: His life in 40 pictures
Further down Tenby’s high street, John Mather runs the Nook gift shop.
He said: “They’re [second homeowners] an all-year customer. Tenby has a lot of visitors that just come during the holiday times, whereas the second homeowners are here all year.
“They kit out their homes, they’ve got a disposable income, and they support the businesses in town.”
Ifor William Hywel has owned his second home in Tenby harbour for the last 30 years.
His council tax for the property has risen from around £2,000 to £7,000 a year.
“I understand the theory behind it, but frankly I don’t think it works. It’s just another tax,” he said.
Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Sky News
He doesn’t think the policy will help first-time buyers:
“Just look at property values. There’s no way that first-time buyers can actually afford properties like this one. It’s going to drive people away.”
The council hopes the premium will bring in more than £10m a year.
Be the first to get Breaking News
Install the Sky News app for free
Cabinet member for corporate finance and efficiencies Cllr Joshua Beynon said: “We’re not trying to ruin the tourist industry locally, we’re trying to find the balance.”
He added: “My view is someone living in that house all year round, buying from local shops, contributing to the local economy, whether that’s through work or whether through spending, is far more effective than having someone in a second home who doesn’t spend as much time here in Pembrokeshire.”
A Welsh government spokesperson said: “We will continue to monitor the effects of this legislation to ensure it is achieving its intended goals.”
